The judge said the arrangement “should ring alarm bells” for any business person.
A filling station owner has lost his High Court challenge against a decision of Revenue not to allow him to offset VAT worth over €450,000 because it was linked to fake fuel invoices.
Mr Justice Michael Twomey rejected a case brought by Fergus Byrne, who operates two convenience stores and service stations in Co Offaly, against a ruling by the Tax Appeals Commission which had confirmed Revenue’s tax assessment.
The court heard Mr Byrne had bought fuel worth approximately €2.5m from three different companies over a three-year period on which he paid VAT of €451,770.
However, no VAT was ever accounted for by those companies to Revenue in relation to the relevant invoices.
Lawyers for Mr Byrne claimed the TAC had made an error on a point of law in finding that Mr Byrne was not entitled to set off the VAT.
They argued that no reasonable commissioner could have drawn the same conclusion that Mr Byrne should have known about the VAT fraud.
However, Mr Justice Twomey disagreed because of the cumulative evidence before the TAC including a triangular payment arrangement whereby Mr Byrne received fuel and invoices from one supplier but paid another firm.
The judge noted that Mr Byrne entered into an arrangement that was not normal in an industry which he knew there was a “well-publicised degree of fraud/criminality”.
He also observed that Mr Byrne was sufficiently concerned about the diesel he bought to have sent samples for scientific testing to check if it was laundered fuel.
Mr Justice Twomey said the arrangement “should ring alarm bells” to any business person.
“The alarm bells should be greater when one is dealing with very large sums of money,” the judge added.
Mr Justice Twomey said a reasonable commissioner could reach the conclusion that the only reasonable explanation for the purchases was that they were connected to VAT fraud.
He acknowledged that another commissioner could have reached a different conclusion but stressed that did not mean the TAC in the present case had made an error on a point of law.
The court heard the issue came to light after Mr Byrne, who had been in the service station business since 2000, was subject to an audit by Revenue in April 2013.
Tax officials determined that invoices worth €12,432 in 2010, €190,356 in 2011 and €248,982 in 2012 were fake.
The High Court heard that Mr Byrne had admitted at a TAC hearing that the triangular payment arrangement was “unusual”.
Mr Byrne told the TAC that he accepted without question that it was “just an arrangement between two companies that that’s the way they want their business done.
He said he had been approached by an agent for one fuel supplier in 2010 who claimed it had an agreement with another company which he knew was linked to one of the country’s largest fuel suppliers, to obtain lower prices.
Mr Byrne said he believed he would have been required to make upfront payments and would not be able to avail of cheaper fuel if he had ordered fuel directly from the second company.
The businessman said he became sufficiently concerned about the arrangement in 2012 to insist that invoices came from the second company in future.
Mr Byrne said he had only ever dealt with agents and had never contacted either company directly.
However, he disagreed that the triangular payment arrangement, the offer of lower prices and the fact that delivery trucks did not have the livery of the supplier should have alerted him to the fraud taking place.
Calls Grow For 24 Hour Garda Station In Edenderry After Arson Attack
Appeal Date Set For Jozef Puska Over Murder Of Ashling Murphy
Offaly Town Demands Meeting With Garda Commissioner And Justice Minister
Ireland’s First Kidney Pancreas Transplant Recipient Dies Aged 68
Quality Of Life To Drive Offaly’s Appeal For Foreign Investment - Anna Marie Delaney
Hundreds Of Mourners Gather For Tadgh Farrell's Funeral
Dancing With The Stars ‘A Once In A Lifetime Opportunity’ - Rose Of Tralee
Uisce Éireann To Submit €6b Water Project Plan
Pedestrian Killed In Midlands Crash
Gardai Arrest Four Men Over Laois Prison Assault
Maura Higgins Set For Traitors US
Man Taken To Hospital Following Alleged Westmeath Assault
Osteoarthritis Programme Launched At Midlands Hospital
Laois County Fire And Rescue Service Welcomes Two New Fire Appliances
Offaly TD Welcomes New IDA Ireland Investment
Gardai Conduct House Searches In Connection With Offaly Arson Attack
Funeral For Offaly Arson Attack Victim To Be Held Today
Emergency Services At Scene Of Offaly Crash
Tadgh Farrell’s Father Denied Compassionate Bail To Attend Son’s Funeral